Military cancels detainee interview in Navy SEAL case

By Chris Carter

The military has canceled the deposition of an alleged terrorist mastermind who claimed that he was assaulted by the military following his capture last year. The law firm Puckett and Faraj, representing Navy SEAL Matthew McCabe, made the announcement on Sunday.

Major General Charles Cleveland, the convening authority for the upcoming special courts-martial for three of the Navy SEALs involved in the operation, has decided to cancel the trip to Iraq to depose Ahmed Hashim Abed. Since the SEALs have a Constitutional right to confront their accuser in court, the alleged terrorist's statements won't be used as evidence for the case.

Click to read more ...

Ten sites join Maritime Tactical Security in support for Navy SEALs

by Kay B. Day

Ten websites are supporting three Navy SEALs facing court martial because of accusations related to a detained terror suspect. The websites represent a Support The Navy SEALs Facebook group with more than 108,000 members, a Christian publisher, Republican congressman Dan Burton (Ind.), Republican congressional candidate Scott Taylor (Va.) who served as a SEAL,  Sark Securities and others. The US Report is among the ten sites supporting the SEALs.

Burton and 40 Republican congressmen have written a formal letter  to the military commander on the SEALs' behalf. Burton wrote, "There is more than enough doubt as to whether these SEALs committed any wrongdoing at all."

Click to read more ...

Capt. Bjork legal fund set up

by Kay B. Day

The family of Capt. Carl Bjork, with urging from friends and supporters, has set up a legal fund to help with his defense. A decorated soldier serving in the U.S. Army, Bjork has been praised by many who have served with him. One soldier who wishes to remain anonymous told The US Report by phone his impression of Bjork, “He’s the ultimate American soldier. He does everything by the book. He even read the Koran before he went to Iraq. He would never do anything unlawful.”

Friends and family of Capt. Carl Bjork (U.S. Army) have set up a defense fund for the soldier who received a Bronze Star and who now stands accused of murder in a case that, based on what is known, makes little sense.
At the website, a synopsis sums up what is known about the case against Bjork: “His accusers, who are the only witnesses/evidence in this alleged crime, are four disgraced former Iraqi police who are imprisoned for the murder of two Iraqi civilians - believed to be Iraqi al queda. Evidence suggests that one of these Iraqi police, an Iraqi Police Colonel, was motivated by revenge to commit these murders, as his brother was beheaded in a public forum by the Iraqi al queda killed in this crime. Now these disgraced Iraqis are looking for a "get out of jail free" ticket, and have accused Carl of ordering the murders to take place. Carl was not even present at the scene of these murders. He simply trained the Iraqi police as part of his duty.”

Click to read more ...

Capt. Bjork’s case referred by general for court martial by March

U.S. Army captain Carl Bjork with children in Iraq. [Photo courtesy of Capt. Bjork's family.]Capt. Carl Bjork, accused of reckless endangerment (1 count) and premeditated murder (2 counts), will proceed to court martial by March, 120 days after he was officially charged and more than 3 years after the alleged acts occurred. Bjork’s attorney Victor Kelley told The US Report in December the accusers are 3 former Iraqi police and a former Iraqi intel officer who are currently detainees in Iraq.

Kelley founded and practices with The National Military Justice Group. He is a retired military officer.

On a blog established by Bjork’s supporters, there’s a brief post announcing the government’s decision to proceed.

Click to read more ...

SEALs will face trial in Iraq so detainee can be present

A judge ruled that trials will be moved to Iraq for Navy SEALs facing various charges about the treatment of an Iraqi detainee, Ahmed Hashim Abed. Abed is believed to be linked to the killings of 4 contractors whose bodies were desecrated and dragged through the streets of Fallujah.

On Monday in Norfolk, the judge set a trial date of April 5 for Navy Petty Officer 2nd class Jonathan Keefe. The trial will be held at Camp Victory.

The Virginian-Pilot, one of the only newspapers following this story consistently, said, “The military judge, Cmdr. Tierney Carlos, decided to move the trial to Iraq after military officials said they would make Abed available to give a deposition but not to testify. Carlos said Keefe has a right to face his accuser in court.”
Maj. Gen. Charles T. Cleveland who heads up Special Operations Command Central said the accusers were actually members of the U.S. military. But because the detainee is the alleged victim—in essence, the indirect accuser—the judge insisted he be present for the trials.

In a hearing for Petty Officer 1st Class Julio A. Huertas Jr., the judge made the same decision. Huertas’ trial is scheduled for the week after Keefe’s.

The paper said a hearing for Petty Officer 2nd Class Matthew McCabe who allegedly punched Abed will be held this week.

The military had planned for Abed to give his statement via videotape.

Betty Kilbride, author and staunch advocate for the SEALs at the Facebook group Support the Navy SEALs Who Captured Ahmed Hashim Abed, said, “[T]here is no jury in this case... Court-Martials are not convened with a jury of peers, it is comprised of the convening authority (a group of officers usually who are hand picked from the JAG pool by the very people who are bringing the charges – it’s not a fair court to the service member).”

Many in the group believe the SEALs are being railroaded in a political witch hunt as a result of trickle down policy from Washington. The Facebook group supporting the SEALs now has 101,422 members.

A defense fund has been set up for the SEALs at Maritime Tactical Security.

[Disclosure: The editor has advocated for dropping charges against the SEALs and she has also contributed to their defense fund.]

SEALs Tired of Watching Their Back says source

by Chris Carter

Exclusive to The US Report

CORONADO, Calif. (Oct. 29, 2009) A Basic Underwater Demolition/SEAL (BUDS) student moves through the weaver during an obstacle course evolution in the first phase of training at Naval Amphibious Base Coronado. The Course is one of many physically strenuous exercises that are part of the seven weeks of first phase. The Navy SEALs are the maritime component of U.S. Special Forces and are trained to conduct a variety of operations from the sea, air and land. [U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Kyle D. Gahlau/Released] The US Report recently interviewed a Navy SEAL officer, who wishes to remain anonymous, on the effect the upcoming Special Courts-Martial of three SEALs has on the special warfare community. Petty Officers Matthew McCabe, Julio Huertas, and Jonathan Keefe face various charges over allegedly mishandling Ahmed Hashim Abed when they participated in the capture of the man authorities believe is a most-wanted al Qaeda leader.

Abed is the suspected mastermind of a 2004 ambush that killed four Blackwater security contractors – including a former SEAL – in Fallujah, Iraq.

Military charge sheets show allegations against the SEAL3; among them,  that McCabe is accused of punching Abed in the midsection.  Other charges include allegations that Huertas and Keefe covered up the incident.

“This prosecution will inevitably drive more quality SEALs out of the community,” TUSR's source stated. “Many enlisted SEALs are already at odds end with the leadership and rules of engagement.”

Click to read more ...

Prosecutors want first trial delayed in Navy SEAL3 cases paper says

Commentary by Kay B. Day

NORFOLK (July 18, 2009) U.S. Navy SEALS conduct a fast-rope insertion demonstration from an MH-60S Sea Hawk helicopter into the Chesapeake Bay during a capabilities exercise at Naval Amphibious Base, Little Creek. The Naval Special Warfare community displayed its capabilities during the 40th UDT-SEAL East Coast Reunion celebrations. Events are planned throughout the weekend to honor UDT/SEAL history, heritage, and families. (U.S. Navy photo by Mass Communication Specialist 2nd Class Joshua T. Rodriguez/Released) The Virginian-Pilot said government lawyers are asking for a delay in the first trial scheduled for the Navy SEAL3. Petty Officer 1st Class Julio Huertas Jr.’s  court-martial is set for Monday, Jan. 11, in Norfolk. Huertas is charged with dereliction of duty because the government alleges he did not keep the detainee safe. He is also charged with giving a false statement to authorities in response to questions about alleged minor injuries to the detainee.

The paper reported, “His civilian attorney, Monica Lombardi, said government lawyers have asked to reschedule the trial for March 29, which she opposes.”

Lombardi has asked for more information about accusations against Huertas. Lombardi had also asked for additional information when The US Report corresponded with her by email in early December.

The US Report located the charge sheets with general details of allegations against SO2 Jonathan E. Keefe, SO2 Matthew V. McCabe and SO1 Julio A. Huertas by following a link posted at the military justice website CAAFlog.

Click to read more ...